Tuesday, April 23, 2013

The Skillful Teacher

Rob is finishing up his master's degree and passed on a book of his for me to borrow.  It's similar to Fred Jones' and the Wongs' book but a bit meatier and more academic -not to discredit the other two authors' work at all.

He recommended a few chapters and I've read through most of them taking notes as I go.  I'm a bit pressed for time so I tried to glean what I could from the book.  I have to be realistic. I have only so much time before school starts and I'm better of prepping with what I know than trying to digest a hefty amount of information and then having no plans!

There is some overlap with past readings but some information differs.  Heck, I'll take the reinforcement by itself any day.



Expectations

Students have to know with certainty what a teacher wants - clarity
When students respect their teacher, the role of the expectations of the teacher become that much more influential

The three chief expectations are:
1.       This is important and I expect you to understand why
2.       You can do it
3.       I won't give up on you

Effective effort is the key to achievement
Effective teachers believe in their students, but also their subjects

A standard is a level of performance a teacher finds acceptable
An expectation is how a teacher things/believes/predicts students will do

There are 4 general categories for teachers to set standards of performance:

1.       Quality and quantity of work
a.       Explain and show students examples of what is expected of them for different assignments.
2.       Work habits and work procedures
a.       Reading directions, behavior in the classroom, knowing procedures, how to submit assignments, etc
3.       Business and housekeeping routines
a.       How to clean up after certain activities, how roll is taken
4.       Interpersonal behavior
a.       General good behavior (respect, diligence, asking questions when you don't understand, help others, general behavior conducive to everyone's learning)

***You must make sure standards are explicit and obvious.  They must also be challenging but attainable.  Learning experiences must match the different needs of students so they all progress towards meeting and achieving the standards set.***

Communicating Standards

Effective teachers share these common behaviors

1.       Directly/Explicitly communicate their standards and expectations
2.       Are very specific and clear in what they expect
3.       Communicate standards repeatedly
4.       Communicate standards with positivity ("Of course, you can do this, it's just how it's done!")
5.       Teachers model to students how something is done but also follow the same standards themselves
6.       Personally interact/have ''face time'' with students
7.       No excuses - teachers hold students accountable, no one slides. This means having consequences that are intended to improve performance when it's poor without getting angry
8.       When students are improving, recognize this!  If they write a great paper, post it up as an example for everyone to see
9.       Have logical consequences for poor performance, ie missing an assignment or doing such a bad job that chicken scratch would be closer to what you wanted.  These consequences are always made explicit in advance.  The must be logical, not punitive, and delivered with appropriate affect.
10.   Tenacity.  The message is that the teacher cares and won't give up on a student but won't hold their hand to make them do everything.  How to convey tenacity is a balancing act that varies per student.
11.   Feedback on student work is extremely influential.  Feedback is information about how a person did relative to how they could have done while considering what you hold up as ideal. Establish and communicate standards to set the stage for feedback.  Feedback must be succinct.

Get it out of your head that intelligence influenced enough by genetics to determine absolute performance.  It plays a hand, but not a big a hand as we've all been led to believe.  So really believe in students, really truly believe in them and their efforts

The successful and confident tend to attribute success to internal factors and failure to external.   

While unsuccessfully and low confidence individuals tend to attribute both successes and failures to external causes.  They just can't win!

Teacher standards and expectations must be carefully considered.  Ideally you should have both high standards and expectations just lofty enough that students must put forth effort to satisfy each.  No one likes to discount successes b/c the task was easy and no one likes to fail repeatedly b/c a goal is constantly out of reach.  Also, make sure students know you know your expectations and standards are challenging and celebrate their efforts when they meet them.

Expectations of students are set by what we think we know about them (high achievers vs strugglers) and it effects 5 factors that then influence individual student performance.

1.       Climate/friendliness
2.       Demands/opportunities to learn
3.       Persistence/how much we encourage and how positively
4.       Frequency of interaction
5.       Feedback frequency and positivity levels

High Standards/High Expectations

There are 10 "Arenas" of classroom life to build confidence with:

1.       Calling on students
a.       All students must get the message that their input is important, that they are capable of higher-level thinking, that their teacher believes they have important things to offer.
2.       Responding to students answers (right after they give an answer)
a.       Responses can either engage students or shut them down
b.      An important consideration is "Wait time"
                                                               i.      After asking a question, wait 3-5 seconds before opening the floor up to responses.  It creates richer thoughts and answers.
c.       Then there's "wait time 2"
                                                               i.      After their response, wait again.  This can trigger other students to chime in, give the same student more time to think, and/or help you create a thoughtful response as well.
d.      When students have trouble with questions, guide them and walk them through the discussion you're helping them be a part of. 
                                                               i.      This builds positive expectations and a positive environment.
e.      Other responses:
                                                               i.      Follow up question to double check or extend
                                                             ii.      Ask students to elaborate
                                                            iii.      Acknowledge students answers non-judgmentally to keep the floor open
                                                           iv.      Restating in fuller language
f.        Handling Praise
                                                               i.      Keep it specific, keep it relevant to the specific task/effort, meant it god dammit, carry yourself like you mean it, and match your words to the particular student.
                                                             ii.      You can also use their past successes in current praise, lil reminders of their improvements or consistency
                                                            iii.      Attribute success to effort and ability but go a lil heavy on the effort
3.       When students don't answer
a.       You don't want a student to feel pressure or embarrassment so stay on your toes to keep them 'safe'
b.      Here's how to progress things.  Obviously don't do all of these things, do a few in a logical order
                                                               i.      Wait time 1
                                                             ii.      Repeat question
                                                            iii.      Give'm a cue
                                                           iv.      Ask a simpler question or a fact only question
                                                             v.      Give choices for answers
                                                           vi.      Ask for a yes or no response
                                                          vii.      Ask the questions that get the answers "I need more time to think" or " I don't know yet, please come back to me"
4.       Giving help
a.       When students ask for help, you need to be careful not to shut them down with negativity or frame undesirable expecations.
b.      So what you do is point out how students can use what they already know or have at their disposal (instructions, examples, past work) to help themselves and that you'll check back with them in a bit to see how things are going.
c.       You never want them to feel your being negative or expressing no, nor do you want them to think you're an answer machine.  Your role is TEACHER.
d.      Be careful to help students that aren't looking for help.  This can create nasty expectations in their heads.
5.       Responding to student performance
a.       "Good" feedback improves learning and is best put to use by sprinkling it throughout the class/day not dumping it all at once
b.      The aim is a high volume of specific, useful feedback and to pay attention to your embedded messages.
c.       When students perform poorly, our feedback must convey that we believe they can do better and we're here to help them find
d.      When student performance changes, guide them to understand why it's changing.  Maybe they're trying harder and this needs to be celebrated.  Ya know, casually and such.
6.       Dealing with errors
a.       Believers of innate intelligence see tests/numbers as the end all.  Therefore low numbers are a sign of weakness and should be avoided/ignored.
                                                               i.      This type struggles to improve relative to...
b.      Believes of effort based intellect tend to see such as feedback to work with.
c.       Dealing with student attitude towards this issue is very important.
7.       Grades
a.       Retests should be counted, not averaged.  Grades aren't a ****ing game! We want proficiency so if a retest gets you that then good!  If you suspect students using this loophole to buy study time, make it a minor PITA by requiring afterschool study sessions or something similar for each retest
8.       Handling students not getting 'it'
a.       First off, encourage students to be open and seek help during class but after as well
b.      Plan for "reteaching loops" with activities for those not a part of the session.
                                                               i.      The most important part of the loop is the teacher's tenacity and the confidence they have that students will get it if they stick with it.
9.       Grouping/tracking
a.       Don't worry about this
10.   Giving and Negotiating Tasks and Assignments
a.       Publicly recognize the difficulty of assignments so students know you know how hard they're working
b.      Never be anything but positive with students when talking about the work they are going to do.
c.       Keep in mind your body language.

Teaching Effective Effort

You can't exert effort properly unless you...

1.       Allow for enough time
2.       Can focus without distraction
3.       Are reaching out for help and know where to get it.  Are you being resourceful?
4.       Are using the right strategies.  Students do better when they're teacher has helped them identify handy strategies
5.       Listening to the teacher's useful feedback.
6.       Commit to difficult tasks and don't give up.

Remember, be positive! Not a nauseating, saccharine, punchable face.  Just a positive person with an optimistic outlook.


Routines

Routines:
1.      Are explicit and brought to student's attention
2.      Are specific and explained clearly
3.      Are repeated to make sure students absorb them
4.      Are repeated to make sure students absorb them
5.      Are repeated to make sure students absorb them
6.      Are communicated with positive expectancy
7.      Modeled
8.      Practiced until mastered
9.      Nothing short of standard (mastery) is accepted

Planning

Failure to plan is planning for failure.

Teachers can make 21 planning decisions.  Thirteen of which are indispensible (first 13 in this list)
1.      Know the curriculum.  Know what the students must know and bear it in mind when you plan.  The connections must be very plain.
2.      Know and articulate the mastery objective(s) to students
3.      Plan how to communicate the objective(s) without any ambiguity.  1 + 1 = 2
4.      Decide what evidence you'll use as confirmation of student mastery
5.      Pay attention to your evidence from whenever about who is getting it and who isn't
6.      In light of evidence, plan a reteaching strategy
7.      Pick the best materials to convey learning objectives.  Variety brightens the classroom
8.      Anticipate confusion and have alternate strategies.  Preteaching can help.
9.      Choose student learning experiences that students will find engaging and guide their learning
10.  Check that the task(s) are logical and actually progressing students towards the goal
11.  Decide when and how you will gather evidence of student learning during or after the lesson
12.  Plan how students will 'go public' with their learning
13.  Select a strategy for getting students cognitively active in summarizing and assimilating their new learning.
14.  Decide how you'll prime the class for the lesson.  What knowledge do you want to prime?  Find out what they already know
15.  Arrange environmental variables beforehand (space and time)
16.  Choose the effort strategies you may explicitly teach (student self evaluation, use of 'effective effort rubric'
17.  Decide specific interactive moves you'll make to make sure students are engaged with important themes and issues.
18.  Determine how to diversify for different student learning styles
19.  Determine how much support, cuing, and help students might need while doing the work, this can include peer help
20.  Decide what lesson extensions/challenges you'll have for those students that are ready
21.  Choose homework and how and when to explain it and what it's for

Assessment

I wish I had time read thoroughly, digest, and fully implement the information in this chapter, but at the moment I'm a bit short on time.  I'm doing a very cursory read through in hopes of gleaning some gems I can use for the students' benefit.  Maybe I'll be able to read through it at a later time.

Purpose of assessment

1.      To make summative statements
a.      about students meeting course objectives
2.      To certify students
a.      as competent in...
3.      To signal clearly
a.      what knowledge is important
4.      To make instructional decisions
a.      about where to start with instruction, which skills are mastered and which need more work
5.      To give feedback to students
a.      about students ' strengths, weaknesses, and interests
6.      To give feedback to teachers
a.      about effectiveness of instruction and curriculum
7.      To report progress to parents and communities
a.      about any and all of the above
8.      To elevate the curriculum so as to provide meaningful, higher-level thinking tasks for all students
9.      To sort rank or compare students
a.      for honors and awards or admission into programs with limited enrollment
10.  For placement
a.      in courses, grades, or levels
11.  To predict
a.      success in school, a job, or a course

Twelve Components of Classroom Assessment

1.      Determining the assessment task
a.      Teacher generates the task as well as exactly what students are ideally expected to produce
2.      Communicating standards of performance
a.      The above (1a) are share explicitly with students
3.      Assessing prior knowledge
a.      Assess readiness and accuracy of prior knowledge.  This helps prepare teacher how to handle with students in need.
4.      Frequent data collection and record keeping by the teacher
a.      Regular informal assessment events (observations, short written or oral tasks)
5.      Frequent high-quality feedback to students
a.      Daily, descriptive, non-judgmental feedback to facilitate improvement
6.      Student self-assessment
a.      Students are taught how to regularly use criteria for self-assessment and peer feedback
7.      Student record keeping about progress
a.      Students regularly keep record of their own learning progress.  This ensures accountability and self-awareness
8.      Frequent error analysis by the teacher
a.      Teacher determines what confusions and misconceptions exist
9.      Error analysis by the students
a.      Students analyze their own tests and such using the feedback you provide to determine their own gaps in knowledge
10.  Planning and implementing reteaching
a.      Teacher uses data on student performance to plan reteaching loops
11.  Goal setting and action planning by students
a.      Students use feedback and error analysis to set SMART goals. Specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and time-based.
12.  Reporting systems on student progress including three-way conferences
a.      Students report on their goals-and progress toward achieving those goals- at three-way conferences with teachers and parents

Classroom Climate

Climate revolves around three things: community and mutual support, confidence and risk taking, influence and control.  Each has important subcomponents
1.      Community and Mutual support
a.      Knowing others
b.      Greeting acknowledging, listening, responding, and affirming
c.       Group identiy, responsibility, and interdependence
d.      Cooperative learning, social skills, class meetings, group dynamics
e.      Problem solving and conflict resolution
2.      Confidence and Risk Taking.  Believing that...
a.      Mistakes help vs being signs of weakness
b.      Care, perseverance, and craftsmanship count vs fast = smarter
c.       Good students solicit help and lots of feedback vs doing it by themselves
                                                              i.      We live in a world full of others after all
d.      Effort and effective strategies are the main determinants of success vs innate intellect
e.      Everyone is capable of high achievement vs only the few can achieve at a high level.
3.      Influence and Control
a.      Empowering students to influence the pace of the class
b.      Negotiating the rules of the "classroom game"
                                                              i.      Students are a part of creating certain procedures and such
c.       Teaching students to use the principles of learning and other learning strategies
d.      Students using knowledge of learning style and making choices
e.      Students and their communities as sources of knowledge